Overtime: Awards and nominations
| Year | Category | Subcategory | Info |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2011 | Louisville Fright Night Film Fest | Winner Festival Prize | Best Actor (John Wells) |
| 2011 | Louisville Fright Night Film Fest | Winner Festival Prize | Best Soundtrack (Jason Paige, ThoughtFly Films) |
| 2011 | Louisville Fright Night Film Fest | Winner Festival Prize | Best Actress (Sebrina Scott) |
| 2011 | Louisville Fright Night Film Fest | Winner Festival Prize | Best Action Film (Matt Niehoff, Brian Cunningham, ThoughtFly Films) |
| 2011 | Louisville Fright Night Film Fest | Winner Festival Prize | Filmmakers of the Year (Matt Niehoff, Brian Cunningham, ThoughtFly Films) |
| 2011 | Louisville Fright Night Film Fest | Winner Festival Prize | Best One-Liner (John Wells) |
| 2011 | Louisville Fright Night Film Fest | Winner Festival Prize | Best of the Fest (Brian Cunningham, Matt Niehoff, ThoughtFly Films) |
| 2011 | Louisville Fright Night Film Fest | Winner Festival Prize | Best Cinematography (Brian Cunningham, ThoughtFly Films) |