Return to Halloweentown: Awards and nominations
| Year | Category | Subcategory | Info |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 | Art Directors Guild | Nominee Excellence in Production Design Award | Television Movie or Mini-Series (Edward L. Rubin) |
| 2007 | Online Film & Television Association | Nominee OFTA Television Award | Best Production Design in a Motion Picture or Miniseries |
| 2007 | Primetime Emmy Awards | Nominee Primetime Emmy | Outstanding Art Direction for a Miniseries, or Movie (Edward L. Rubin, Ken Kirchner) |