Return to Never Land: Awards and nominations
| Year | Category | Subcategory | Info |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2003 | Annie Awards | Nominee Annie | Outstanding Music in an Animated Feature Production (Joel McNeely, Jonatha Brooke) |
| 2003 | Annie Awards | Nominee Annie | Outstanding Voice Acting in an Animated Feature Production (Corey Burton) |
| 2003 | Young Artist Awards | Nominee Young Artist Award | Best Performance in a Voice-Over Role (Spencer Breslin) |
| 2003 | Young Artist Awards | Nominee Young Artist Award | Best Performance in a Voice-Over Role - Age Ten or Under (Andrew McDonough) |