Blue Exorcist: Awards and nominations
| Year | Category | Subcategory | Info |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Behind the Voice Actors Awards | Winner BTVA People's Choice Voice Acting Award | Best Male Lead Vocal Performance in an Anime Television Series/OVA (Bryce Papenbrook) |
| 2014 | Behind the Voice Actors Awards | Winner BTVA People's Choice Voice Acting Award | Best Vocal Ensemble in an Anime Television Series/OVA (Bryce Papenbrook, Johnny Yong Bosch, Christine Marie Cabanos, Kyle Hebert, Mona Marshall, Brian Beacock, Kira Buckland, Sam Riegel, Wendee Lee, Kirk Thornton) |
| Year | Category | Subcategory | Info |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Behind the Voice Actors Awards | Nominee BTVA Anime Dub Television/OVA Voice Acting Award | Best Male Vocal Performance in an Anime Television Series/OVA in a Supporting Role (Kirk Thornton) |
| 2014 | Behind the Voice Actors Awards | Nominee BTVA Anime Dub Television/OVA Voice Acting Award | Best Female Vocal Performance in an Anime Television Series/OVA in a Supporting Role (Wendee Lee) |
| 2014 | Behind the Voice Actors Awards | Nominee BTVA Anime Dub Television/OVA Voice Acting Award | Best Male Lead Vocal Performance in an Anime Television Series/OVA (Bryce Papenbrook) |
| 2014 | Behind the Voice Actors Awards | Nominee BTVA Anime Dub Television/OVA Voice Acting Award | Best Vocal Ensemble in an Anime Television Series/OVA (Bryce Papenbrook, Johnny Yong Bosch, Christine Marie Cabanos, Kyle Hebert, Mona Marshall, Brian Beacock, Kira Buckland, Sam Riegel, Wendee Lee, Kirk Thornton) |